Which is the bigger eco-villain: plastic or paper?

Plastic is held up as a symbol of the environmental damage of disposable culture. But does it deserve its bad reputation?

Disturbing pictures of dead seabirds with lighters, bottle caps and plastic bags in their guts are among the images that have contributed to plastic's bad reputation. But research by Oregan State University published this week suggests that the size of the " great garbage patch", an accumulation of plastic debris that floats in the Pacific, has been " grossly exaggerated". Rather than being twice the size of Texas, as is commonly reported, studies suggest the " cohesive" patch is less than 1% of the size of Texas.

Clearly, plastic does pose a threat to wildlife. But has its status as an environmental villain been exaggerated? Many of the world's most potent environmental threats are invisible, but plastic loiters in trees and rivers as a reminder of the consequences of our consumption. However, in some cases, plastic is environmentally the better option.

For example Riverford Organics, one of the largest vegetable box schemes in the UK, discovered that swapping short-lived cardboard boxes for more durable plastic ones could reduce the company's carbon footprint from packaging by 70%. There was one problem. " Our customers hate plastic with a vengence, " the company's website says. Even though paper and cardboard are responsible for 85% of the carbon footprint from packaging, virtually all complaints are about the plastic punnets and bags, which are responsible for only 8% of the footprint.

Guy Watson, the founder of Riverford, was prepared to make the investment in plastic boxes, but decided to test the water with a customer survey last summer. Around third of respondents were " pretty vehemently opposed" to the change and as a result, the company bottled out, concerned that plastic boxes would put off new and existing customers who think plastic is environmentally unfriendly and ugly. " You have to be quite courageous to fly in the face of people's intuitive judgement, " he says, " and some might say commercially foolhardy."

Watson is unwilling to take that risk at the moment, but says he'd " be surprised if we don't have plastic boxes within five or 10 years". Meanwhile, the company is investigating the possibility of using bamboo.

Other retailers have had more success in switching to plastic. Marks & Spencer now uses the material for its 25cl wine bottles and will trial plastic for full-sized bottles this spring. The supermarket introduced the new bottles because less energy is required to manufacture them than a glass bottle, and the lightweight bottles reduce the distribution carbon footprint. There were no reported complaints, with customers apparently enjoying the lighter weight.

So is the future plastic fantastic? Julie Hill, author of the forthcoming book The Secret Life of Stuff, says that plastic has environmental potential because it is very durable, adaptable, flexible and light. Plastic's durability, for instance, means it can have a lower impact (if re-used, as Riverford had planned) than materials such as cardboard, despite the fact that plastic has two to three times more embodied carbon than paper and card.

Unfortunately, Hill says, plastic's potential is often unfulfilled: plastic products are frequently used only briefly and thrown away. According to the government's Waste and Resources Action Programme, 85% of local authorities in England collect plastic bottles, and only 26% collect other rigid mixed plastics. If plastic is allowed to escape into the environment it is a hazard as it mostly doesn't biodegrade.

Ultimately, it all depends on how a material, whether plastic or paper, is used – and what happens at the end of its life. Plastic pollution such as the " great garbage patch" of the Pacific may capture our imaginations, but plastic's bad reputation is not always borne out by the facts. Just because a brown cardboard box looks greener than plastic, that doesn't mean it is.[23]

 

Ex.7. Look at the given list “What can we do to prevent pollution? ” Read and translate it, then try to add some new points.

Ex.8. Arrange discussions on the following.

Environmental protection as a crucial problem of today.

Love of nature as an essential part of a child’s upbringing.

 

 

 

[1] http: //www.goodreads.com/book/popular_by_date/2010

 

[2] http: //www.maggiestiefvater.com/linger.php

[3] http: //shelf-life.ew.com/2010/03/30/stephenie-meyers-novella-the-short-second-life-of-bree-tanner-and-the-red-cross/

[4] http: //www.sutki.net/thefile/13624-dzhoan_rouling__joanne_rowling.html

[5] Видео материалы предоставлены сайтом http: //www.sutki.net/thefile/13624-dzhoan_rouling__joanne_rowling.html

[6] http: //www.allreaders.com/topics/Info_7220.asp

[7] Тексты и изображения предоставлены сайтом http: //sueysbooks.blogspot.com

[8] Аракин В.Д. Практический курс английского языка: 5 курс. М.: ВЛАДОС, 2006. – c. 57-58.

[9] Аракин В.Д. Практический курс английского языка: 5 курс. М.: ВЛАДОС, 2006. – c. 65.

[10] Аракин В.Д. Практический курс английского языка: 5 курс. М.: ВЛАДОС, 2006. – c. 65 – 66.

[11] http: //en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charlie_Chaplin

[12] http: //www.cinema.com/articles/7666/chronicles-of-narnia-the-voyage-of-the-dawn-treader-the-movie-review.phtml

[13] http: //www.cinema.com/articles/7667/tourist-the-movie-review.phtml

[14] Аракин В.Д. Практический курс английского языка: 5 курс. М.: ВЛАДОС, 2006. – c.89-90

[15] Аракин В.Д. Практический курс английского языка: 5 курс. М.: ВЛАДОС, 2006. – c.90

[16] Аракин В.Д. Практический курс английского языка: 5 курс. М.: ВЛАДОС, 2006. – c.90

[17] Аракин В.Д. Практический курс английского языка: 5 курс. М.: ВЛАДОС, 2006. – c.91

[18] Аракин В.Д. Практический курс английского языка: 5 курс. М.: ВЛАДОС, 2006. – c.96-97

[19] Аракин В.Д. Практический курс английского языка: 5 курс. М.: ВЛАДОС, 2006. – c.97

[20] Аракин В.Д. Практический курс английского языка: 5 курс. М.: ВЛАДОС, 2006. – c.97

[21] Аракин В.Д. Практический курс английского языка: 5 курс. М.: ВЛАДОС, 2006. – c.181-183

[22] Аракин В.Д. Практический курс английского языка: 5 курс. М.: ВЛАДОС, 2006. – c.183-185

[23] http: //www.guardian.co.uk/environment/green-living-blog/2011/jan/07/plastic-eco-villain-paper

⇐ Предыдущая123

Поделиться:

Популярное:

1. An overhaul of its American beverages business has helped Cadbury Schweppes take market share from its bigger rivals
2. Choose the conjunction which fits the meaning of the sentence.
3. Nevertheless, the laser no doubt has innumerable other applications which we are still to discover.
4. Read the text and say which part of it describes the following.
5. Rubber and plastics stereotypes
6. State which of the comparative structures represent metaphors and similes
7. Task 2. Fill the gaps in the sentences below with the words and expressions from the box. There are two expressions which you don't need to use
8. Underline one sentence in each letter which seems most important to you.
9. V. Look at the groups of words below. Which is the odd one out in each group?
10. Variation number - number, which matched (according to the degree of increase or decrease) the options and their corresponding frequency
11. Would you like egg dish? Which would you prefer?